Pfister Real Estate - HOME | Pfister Real Estate

Welcome to Pfister Real Estate Group

With over 29 years of experience, Pfister Real Estate Group, led by Amy Pfister, offers elite, white-glove service in both New York and Florida. Whether you’re buying, selling, or investing, our expert team provides seamless transactions and unparalleled market expertise.

• Licensed in New York & Florida
• Residential & Commercial Specialists
• Trusted by Industry Leaders & Former Pro Athletes

Meet Your Team

Another Home Sold, Another Dream Realized!

We take your home search seriously

Find Your Dream Home

The Pfister Real Estate Group, led by Amy Pfister, is a premier real estate team serving Buffalo, New York, and Sarasota, Florida. With over 20 years of experience, Amy is a top REALTOR® in Western New York, known for handling some of the region’s most significant transactions—including those for celebrities and professional athletes. As a broker and owner of two elite real estate offices, she has built a reputation for trust, integrity, and white-glove service.
Amy’s love for Sarasota began in childhood, spending summers biking and golfing through The Meadows. Now, as the leader of The Pfister Group at Premier Sotheby’s International Realty, she brings that passion—and her decades of expertise—to buyers and sellers in Florida’s Gulf Coast market.
For sellers, we provide high-tech, cutting-edge marketing and staging strategies to maximize exposure and success, ensuring your property gets in front of the right buyers.
For buyers, we offer expert guidance from the first search to the final closing, helping you find the perfect home and neighborhood to match your lifestyle—whether it’s in the heart of Buffalo or the paradise of Sarasota.
Beyond the transaction, our team provides a full suite of services to support homeowners before and after closing. With deep market knowledge, unmatched dedication, and a commitment to putting our clients first, we make real estate success effortless.
With The Pfister Real Estate Group, every deal is a hole-in-one.

'Our mission is to integrate unparalleled and outstanding service, while maintaining Integrity, Loyalty, Passion & Trust. Our goal is to have every client become a part of our extended family.'
- Amy Pfister

Specializing in lifestyle properties

RESIDENTIAL COMMERCIAL VACANT LAND RENTAL

WNY & Ellicottville

Waterfront Living

Vacation & Home Rentals

Contact Amy

Testimonials

Amy Pfister

Amy Pfister | Broker & Real Estate Advisor

With a reputation built on exceptional service, cutting-edge marketing, and industry expertise, Amy Pfister is a top-performing broker and real estate advisor serving Buffalo, NY, and Sarasota, FL. As the owner of two elite real estate offices, Amy has spent over 20 years helping buyers and sellers navigate the market with precision and care.
Her commitment to integrity, innovation, and white-glove service has made her the trusted choice for high-profile clients, including Buffalo Bills and Buffalo Sabres players and coaches. Over the years, she has worked with Jim Kelly, Marshawn Lynch, Thurman Thomas, Dixon Knox, John McCargo, and many others, handling some of the region’s most significant transactions.
Amy’s success is driven by her state-of-the-art technology, strategic marketing expertise, and deep market knowledge. Whether assisting first-time homebuyers, luxury sellers, or high-profile investors, she provides a seamless, high-touch experience that exceeds expectations.
With roots in both Western New York and Sarasota, Amy understands the unique appeal of both markets. Her passion for real estate, combined with her dedication to her clients, ensures that every transaction is handled with expertise, professionalism, and a personal touch.

We are pledged to the letter and spirit of U.S. policy for the achievement of equal housing opportunity
throughout the Nation. We encourage and support an affirmative advertising and marketing program in
which there are no barriers to obtaining housing because of race, color, religion, sex, handicap, familial
status, or national origin.

Luxury should be expected.